I'm going to pick up something new tomorrow. 

Trying to find a replacement for my Reign Supreme, which was my favorite ball ever.  It is currently toast, so I would like to find something similar.

Currently using:
Reign Supreme (Probably 500 games on it)
Reign (Not comfortable with it unless i'm playing a tight line in deep)
Ebonite Bash (Currently my go to ball even though it is my oldest)
Virtual Gravity (Go to if I feel like moving outside and throwing it hard)

I throw the ball moderately fast with a lot of hand, so I don't think I need anything to strong.  Currently averaging 213 and 217 in my two leagues. I was thinking that I really like the looks of the frantic.  Those Hybrid covers have been really appealing since I could throw the Supreme on just about anything.

Any advice is appreciated

I always wanted to try the 2nd Dimension and the Virtual Energy, but never got the chance to.  Anything similar to either of those out there right now?

If you are throwing 15 lbs. I would say the hyroad. Both are at 2.57 rg and there differential
 Are very close .48 and .46. However, if you are looking for a slightly stronger replacement look no further than the storm crossroad. Again the core comparison is not too far off between 2.56 and 2.57. And the differential of the crossroad is .52 compared to .48. That means by the numbers, the crossroad flare is a little bit more than the reign supreme.

I think you're really going to like the Frantic.  I've had mine for a little while now and it is a beast when it comes to drier patterns.  Easily one of the most angular balls I've thrown to date and yet it's controllable at the same time.

Only that you would need something to handle heavier conditions, if you like Hybrids, the Defiant Soul is very nice. I have one and it handles oil well, very clean and nice pinch at the end.

True.  I'm glad I have a high rev rate and probably won't run into a ton of oil for the rest of the year. A big oil ball will probably be on my list for the next season.

I'm guessing the Berserk will be enough, especially because i've been working on squaring up and playing a more direct line.