Since switching back to using finger inserts a few years ago, I have only used Vise ovals. I don't care for the lifts. It seems that I destroy grips after only a handful games and then they must be replaced. This is especially true on my middle finger, where I can wear away almost all of the grip edge on the right side.
Since I have nothing to compare to, I was wondering how other companys' grips compare to Vise in both the longevity and firmness department. I think I would prefer a firmer insert (firmer than Vise but not rock-hard without inserts). I'd imagine that the longevity of all inserts are relatively the same (15-20 games before significant change) but I could go through middle finger inserts in as few as 10.
Don
--------------------
"You cannot change the stripes of a leopard."
~Emmitt Smith