Quote: "I can't imagine a doctor suggesting leaving an ACL tear intact?"
SAgosto,
It depends on whether the ACL is completely torn, or just partially torn. A partially torn ACL is quite commonly not surgically repaired, but other things also weigh into the decision.
In my case I was already into my thirties, and most of my "athletic career" was behind me. My employment didn't require me to do lots of physical labor or lifting either. If all the other ligaments were in tact, and I strengthened the muscles around the knee, my surgeon thought I could have a pretty normal life, and 15 years later I have. I still own the knee brace should I need it, but so far, so good.
My doctor could have operated on my knee and been paid much more by my insurance company than his chosen course of action. Perhaps that is one reason why his reputation as an orthopedic surgeon is very good. Some doctors may have been more aggressive, but I'm comfortable with the chosen path. There is no reason that an ACL surgery couldn't be done later, if necessary. It's probably best to try all "less invasive" options first.
stormfanken, all you can do is weigh it all out and listen to the one with the PhD after his name. He has practical experience behind him, whereas each of us only has only our own experience to draw from.
--------------------
Lane Carter, Strike Zone Pro Shops - Salt Lake City, Utah
Brunswick Amateur Staff
www.brunswickbowling.comEdited on 11/13/2008 5:34 PM
