I have had 2 Phenoms, getting ready to drill my 3rd, and I have a Fear Factor.
Both of the Phenoms I have had hooked more than the Fear Factor, by about 4-5 boards in oil.
If you drill the Phenom, simply have the Mb about 2 inches right of the thumb, and also have the MB moved closer to your PAP and it will hook like nothing else.
Both the Phenom and Fear Factor hit well, but I tend to get more messengers with the Phenoms.